Skip to content
Research

Removing online commercial curbs can hurt consumers

By Wei Zhang
2 min read
sidewalks 2
sidewalks 2
In this article (5)

Hong Kong manufacturers and retailers that increasingly use e-commerce may know that their contracts with EU companies may contain vertical restraints on online distribution. Competition authorities across Europe are currently discussing the appropriate treatment of such restraints under competition law.

This is being done with a view to preventing distributors from imposing more restrictions on online retailers than on their rivals in traditional brick-and-mortar shops, Hong Kong Trade Development Council Research (HKTDC Research) has said in a report.

The UK’s Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) commissioned a report from independent consultants in order to know why businesses use these restrictions and how these may affect consumers, both positively and negatively. The report surveyed 33 mostly small and medium-sized UK-based manufacturers and retailers. It was released on 30 March 2016 and will prove to be of interest to e-commerce users, HKTDC Research said.

The businesses interviewed use a wide range of restraints in their contracts, with the most common being selective and exclusive distribution agreements (often excluding online retailers) and recommended retail prices (RRP) for retailers. The participants explained such restrictions by the need “to prevent free-riding” and to “protect brand image”.

Free-riding may occur when customers visit ‘service retailers’ (e.g. providing free advice on products), but purchase the product from a cheaper retailer that does not provide any service support.

Participants who mentioned maintenance of brand image said restrictions “helped signal the high quality of the product and maintain the image of the product (particularly for luxury brands)”.

“could bring about lower retail service standards and a poorer quality experience of the underlying product”

However, the report further shows that the restrictions are also “attractive because they limit the direct competition faced by the relevant manufacturers or retailers, particularly from online channels”, without any consumer benefit.

Hong Kong companies may be interested in the conclusions of this report. In the long term, forbidding these restrictions “could bring about lower retail service standards and a poorer quality experience of the underlying product”. This is likely to hurt consumers, especially for high-tech products. On the other hand, especially in the short run, the absence of such restrictions could cut prices and widen product availability.

The European Commission is also conducting an inquiry into the e-commerce sector. The inquiry was launched on 6 May 2015 and a Preliminary Report is due to be published in mid-2016.

A sector inquiry is an investigation that is carried out by the European Commission into sectors of the economy and into types of agreements across various sectors, when it believes that a market is not working as well as it should, and that breaches of the competition law rules might contribute to the malfunctioning of that market.

Questions & Answers

Q.

What is the primary concern competition authorities have about online distribution restrictions?

A.

Competition authorities are discussing these restrictions to prevent distributors from imposing more limits on online retailers than on traditional brick-and-mortar shops. This aims to ensure fair competition across different retail channels.

Q.

Why do businesses say they use vertical restraints on online distribution?

A.

Businesses explain these restrictions are used to prevent 'free-riding', where customers get advice but buy elsewhere, and to protect brand image. For luxury brands, it helps signal product quality.

Q.

What are the potential negative impacts on consumers if these online restrictions are removed?

A.

In the long term, removing these restrictions could lead to lower retail service standards and a poorer quality experience with products. This is especially true for high-tech items, which could hurt consumers.

Q.

Is the European Commission also looking into online retail practices?

A.

Yes, the European Commission launched an inquiry into the e-commerce sector on 6 May 2015. A Preliminary Report from this investigation is expected to be published in mid-2016.

Reader pulse

Removing online sales curbs is...

18,301 votes so far

Background from the Retail Academy

Background guides from the Retail Academy, free to read.

  • E-commerce

    Omnichannel fulfilment

    Ship-from-store, click and collect, marketplace fulfilment and live commerce, what each model demands from inventory accuracy, staffing and systems, and wher…

    Retail Operations · 11 min read

  • E-commerce

    E-commerce in Brunei

    Which platforms matter in Brunei, how buyers pay, why cash on delivery still shapes the economics, and what a delivered order really costs.

    Asia Market Guides · 9 min read

  • General

    AI in retail

    A practical map of where AI already pays off in retail, from demand forecasting and pricing to search, customer service and store operations, and where the h…

    Retail Operations · 11 min read

  • General

    Loyalty and membership design

    Points, tiers or paid membership: which mechanic fits which business, what a loyalty programme actually costs, and how to measure incremental effect instead…

    Retail Leadership · 11 min read

Weekly Briefing

Asia's retail intelligence, in your inbox

Monday, Wednesday and a Friday Weekly Wrap: the retail stories, numbers and moves that mattered across Asia. Nothing else, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

  • Top industry moves and market shifts
  • Weekly data-driven analysis from across Asia
  • Monday, Wednesday and the Friday Weekly Wrap

Read by retail operators, investors and brand teams across Asia.

Protected by a quick human check. No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click.

SecureGDPR ready