Vietnam drops criminal charge threat against unregistered online businesses

In this article (5)
Successful business owners would have faced up to two years in jail if they failed to register under the previously flawed law. Vietnam’s lawmakers have officially removed a controversial clause from the Penal Code that would have allowed criminal proceedings to be taken against unregistered online businesses with possible jail sentences.
The legislative National Assembly passed the revised Penal Code on Tuesday and agreed to remove Article 292.
Under the article, companies that provide online services without being properly registered would be fined as usual, just like most business offenses. However, businesses that generate a profit of VND50 million ($2,200) or revenue of VND500 million would have faced criminal charges and a potential two-year jail term.
The article was enshrined in the 2015 Penal Code, which itself was scheduled to come into effect last year but was postponed due to multiple errors and loopholes. Article 292 was one of the most controversial parts of the code.
Last October, the government agreed that the rule should be scrapped after it met with strong opposition, including a petition with 6,000 signatures from the local startup community.
The Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry also asked legislators to scrap the article, warning that the rule would have negative impacts on the economy and inhibit the modern era of online services and startups.
Vietnamese authorities have been trying to gain stronger control over online businesses. Hanoi and Ho Chi Minh City have both launched tax collection campaigns targeting retailers on Facebook, the country’s most popular social network.
Hanoi’s tax department this week called on 13,422 retailers that use the Facebook platform to register and pay taxes. The move follows a similar push by Ho Chi Minh City that covered around 13,500 retailers.
Questions & Answers
Q.What specifically allowed criminal proceedings against unregistered online businesses?
What specifically allowed criminal proceedings against unregistered online businesses?
The controversial clause, Article 292, in the Penal Code would have allowed criminal charges for unregistered online businesses that generated significant profits or revenue.
Q.What financial thresholds would have triggered criminal charges under the scrapped article?
What financial thresholds would have triggered criminal charges under the scrapped article?
Businesses would have faced criminal charges if they generated a profit of VND50 million ($2,200) or revenue of VND500 million without proper registration.
Q.Why was the implementation of the 2015 Penal Code delayed?
Why was the implementation of the 2015 Penal Code delayed?
The 2015 Penal Code, which included the controversial Article 292, was postponed from coming into effect last year due to multiple errors and loopholes.
Q.How did businesses and organisations react to Article 292?
How did businesses and organisations react to Article 292?
The rule met strong opposition, including a 6,000-signature petition from the startup community. The Vietnam Chamber of Commerce and Industry also asked legislators to scrap the article.
Reader pulse
Is this a positive step for Vietnam's e-commerce?
16,003 votes so far