Skip to content
Research

Money laundering all too easy in Vietnam?

By Aiko TanakaVietnam
3 min read
money laundry
money laundry
In this article (4)

On February 16, the Hanoi People’s Court will resume a trial over corruption and money laundering charges against Vinashin Ocean Shipping Co., Ltd. (Vinashinlines).

In this trial, defendant Giang Van Hien (67, Ho Chi Minh City) has been charged with helping his son and former director of sales at Vinashinlines Giang Kim Dat (born 1977) to embezzle more than VND259.5 billion ($11.4 million). More specifically, to evade the authorities, Dat told Hien to open 22 foreign currency bank accounts to keep the embezzled money.

Dat used this money to invest in domestic real estates and transfer it abroad. Investigators have verified the sources of these assets and either froze or seized 40 domestic real estate properties, including lands, apartments, villas as well as properties in Singapore and apartments in the UK.

Money laundering is not a new crime in Vietnam, but prosecution has been challenging because of difficulties in proving the offender or the crime. Speaking to reporters on the sidelines of National Assembly meetings, Senior Lieutenant General Le Quy Vuong, Deputy Minister of Public Security, said the Giang Kim Dat case is a classic graft and money laundering case.

In the Penal Code of 1999, this crime was defined in Article 251 as “laundering money and/or property obtained through the commission of crime,” but it was not until the modified Penal Code of 2009 that the term “money laundering” came into official use.

The legal framework exists, but enforcement has been difficult. Experts said money laundering charges have been rare.

Explaining this, Dr Dao Le Thu, director of the comparative legal research centre of Hanoi Law University, said the main reason was the difficulty in following the money trail. This is because financial transactions in Vietnam do not follow international standards and cash still plays a key role in the economy.

Dat used this money to invest in domestic real estates and transfer it abroad.

Besides, regulations are still limited in several ways: there are no charges for self-laundering or for commercial entities, or the fact that the term “money obtained through crimes” in the penal code has not seen further clarification. Whereas other countries might categorise crimes by source or severity, Thu added.

Article 324 of the 2015 Penal Code has defined money laundering behaviours more clearly  as “disguising the legal origin of the money or property obtained through one’s own criminal activities or that one knows to be obtained via another person’s criminal activities.” Therefore, proving money laundering could be easier than it used to be. However, the 2015 Penal Code’s entry into effect has been postponed.

Item 1, Article 3 of Decree 74/2005/ND-CP dated June 7, 2005 on “prevention of money laundering” explains the concept of money laundering as the behaviour of individuals or organisations seeking to legitimise money or property through activities such as:

• Joining directly or indirectly in a transaction involving money or property obtained through criminal activities

• Acquiring, capturing, transiting, converting, transfering, transporting, using and cross-border transporting money or property obtained through the commission of crime

• Investing in a project, a work, contribute capital to a business or find other ways to cloak or disguise or impede verification of origin, the true nature or location, the process of moving or ownership for the money or property obtained through the commission of crime

Questions & Answers

Q.

Why has prosecuting money laundering cases been difficult in Vietnam?

A.

Enforcement has been challenging because financial transactions do not always meet international standards, and cash plays a significant role. Also, regulations have been limited, lacking charges for self-laundering or commercial entities, and the definition of 'money obtained through crimes' needed clarity.

Q.

What methods did Giang Kim Dat use to launder the embezzled money?

A.

Dat instructed his father to open 22 foreign currency bank accounts to hide the funds. He then used this money to invest in domestic real estate and transferred some of it abroad, later acquiring properties in Singapore and the UK.

Reader pulse

Will the Vinashinlines trial significantly deter future money laundering in Vietnam?

19,859 votes so far

Weekly Briefing

Asia's retail intelligence, in your inbox

Monday, Wednesday and a Friday Weekly Wrap: the retail stories, numbers and moves that mattered across Asia. Nothing else, and you can unsubscribe in one click.

  • Top industry moves and market shifts
  • Weekly data-driven analysis from across Asia
  • Monday, Wednesday and the Friday Weekly Wrap

Read by retail operators, investors and brand teams across Asia.

Protected by a quick human check. No spam, ever. Unsubscribe in one click.

SecureGDPR ready