Finance Ministry Seeks Review Of Yes Bank Ruling

In this article (7)
The finance ministry has sought a review of the Supreme Court’s October 15 judgment that set aside the ₹8,415-crore write-off of Yes Bank’s additional tier-1 (AT-1) bonds.
Earlier this month, Yes Bank and the Reserve Bank of India (RBI) also filed review petitions seeking reconsideration of the ruling, which upheld a Bombay High Court decision finding that the administrator lacked authority to write down bonds not covered under the reconstruction scheme.
Authority of the administrator
A bench of Justices Dipankar Datta and Augustine George Masih ruled on October 15 that Yes Bank’s administrator had no authority to write down the bonds because the bank’s reconstruction scheme contained no specific provision allowing it. That decision upheld an earlier order from the Bombay High Court.
The Supreme Court found that wiping out the debt outside the formal terms of the reconstruction scheme unfairly shifted institutional failures onto bondholders. Criminal proceedings against its personnel had already been launched after material irregularities were discovered in the bank’s operations.
“The triumvirate of the RBI, the administrator and YES Bank, in conducting the entire affair of dealing with the bonds worth more than ₹8,415 crore, to put it mildly, is questionable,” the judgment said.
Scrutiny over regulatory oversight
Judges criticized the Reserve Bank of India for acting as a bystander while the private lender’s capital deteriorated. The central bank allowed Yes Bank’s Common Equity Tier-1 ratio to sink to 0.6 per cent while business was conducted clandestinely, according to the ruling.
The court concluded that penalizing bondholders for administrative lapses would be unjust.
Implications for bank capital instruments
With the finance ministry joining the central bank and Yes Bank in court, all three institutions are now aligned in demanding a second hearing.
The review petition remains pending before the Supreme Court, leaving the legal status of the 8,415-crore rupee liability unresolved.
Questions & Answers
Q.Why did the Supreme Court overturn the write-off of the AT-1 bonds?
Why did the Supreme Court overturn the write-off of the AT-1 bonds?
The Supreme Court ruled that Yes Bank’s administrator lacked the legal authority to write down the bonds because the bank's reconstruction scheme contained no provision permitting it. The judges held that cancelling the debt outside the formal scheme unfairly penalised bondholders for the institution's own administrative failures.
Q.What criticism did the court direct at the Reserve Bank of India?
What criticism did the court direct at the Reserve Bank of India?
The judges criticised the Reserve Bank of India for acting as a bystander whilst Yes Bank conducted business clandestinely. They noted that the central bank permitted the lender’s Common Equity Tier-1 ratio to decline to 0.6 per cent without intervening, describing the conduct of regulatory authorities as questionable.
Q.Who has asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its ruling?
Who has asked the Supreme Court to reconsider its ruling?
The finance ministry has joined Yes Bank and the Reserve Bank of India in seeking a review of the decision. All three institutions are now aligned before the Supreme Court, leaving the legal status of the 8,415-crore rupee liability unresolved whilst the petition remains pending.
Reader pulse
Will the Supreme Court overturn its Yes Bank bond ruling?
23,026 votes so far